Give the sea! Try-dive, snorkelling, freediving, boat licence…: treat someone with a Chango Sea gift voucher.

Give a gift voucher
Skip to main content
Understanding scuba diving

Decompression tables: a century of calculations

From Haldane and his goats to the MN90, by way of the US Navy, Bühlmann and PADI’s RDP: where the numbers come from, what they assume, and why they still matter.

Before the computer, there was a waterproof piece of plastic with columns of figures. Many divers trained after 2005 have never used one except to pass an exam.

That is a pity, because these tables tell the story of how we learnt — often badly, sometimes the hard way — what we think we know today. And because the numbers on your computer descend in a direct line from them.

1908: Haldane, the Royal Navy and the goats

At the start of the century, Royal Navy divers were dying or being left disabled with a regularity that eventually became a problem. The British Navy commissioned a study from the Scottish physiologist John Scott Haldane.

He worked in a chamber, on goats — their size was considered close to a man’s — and then on volunteer divers. He drew three ideas from it that have never been abandoned since.

  • The body can be divided into compartments with different speeds. He kept five, with half-times from 5 to 75 minutes.
  • A tissue tolerates supersaturation, up to a threshold. He proposed a 2 to 1 ratio: a tissue can withstand twice the ambient pressure without forming bubbles. The figure would prove too optimistic; the idea was right.
  • The ascent must be staged. Rather than ascending slowly and steadily, you go up in steps and stop: these are the decompression stops, which keep the gradient at the maximum tolerable. That insight is perhaps the most important in the whole history of diving.

His first tables were published in 1908. The structure of the reasoning has not changed in a hundred and eighteen years.

1937–1965: the US Navy scales it up

The US Navy took over the work and pushed it on a scale no university laboratory could have funded. The 1937 tables, then the successive revisions, became the world reference.

The decisive contribution came from Robert Workman in the 1960s. Haldane reasoned in terms of pressure ratios; Workman showed that each compartment tolerates its own maximum nitrogen pressure, which varies with depth. He called it the M-value. It is this formulation that every current model still uses, and it is what your gradient factors adjust.

These tables had a flaw that took a long time to admit: they were validated on young, fit military divers in good health, doing one dive a day. Applied to a fifty-year-old recreational diver doing three dives a day on holiday, they are much less protective than was believed.

1983: Bühlmann and altitude

In Zurich, Dr Albert Bühlmann published work that would equip the entire world. Sixteen compartments, from 4 to 635 minutes, and above all a model that works at altitude — a very Swiss concern, but one that proved decisive.

His other merit is less technical and just as important: he published everything. The equations, the coefficients, the method. Anyone can check, implement, discuss. That is what made ZH-L16 the foundation of almost every computer, and it is an argument we should hear more often in the face of proprietary models.

1988: PADI changes the population

The Recreational Dive Planner, developed under Raymond Rogers for PADI, started from a simple observation: military tables do not describe the recreational diver, who makes shallow, repeated dives, several days in a row.

The resulting DSAT model is calibrated for that use, with real-world trials. The result: longer no-stop times than the US Navy’s on a single dive, which raised eyebrows when it came out, and repetitive-dive management designed for holidays.

SSI, for its part, teaches with no-stop tables derived from the US Navy, while today training mainly in planning with a computer.

1990: the MN90, the tables taught in France

The 1974 Ministry of Labour tables, then the French Navy’s MN90, adopted by the French diving federation (FFESSM), are the reference tool of French diving. They replaced the GERS tables of 1965.

What you should know about their DNA, because it shapes how they are used:

  • Twelve compartments, from 5 to 120 minutes.
  • Validated by several hundred test dives on young, male, trained military divers.
  • Designed for air, at sea level, down to 60 metres.
  • Intended first for one or two dives a day, at constant depth — the famous “square” profile.

That last point is their most practical limit. A table reasons as though you had stayed at your maximum depth the whole time. On a typical Nice dive, where you go down along a wall and then come back up slowly while exploring, that greatly overestimates the load — which is cautious, but costs dive time.

That is exactly what the computer solved: it calculates continuously, at your real depth.

So why still learn them?

A fair question, with real answers.

  • Because you cannot understand a computer you have never contradicted. Working with a table forces you to see the structure: depth, time, repetitive group, residual nitrogen. After that, the screen stops being an oracle.
  • Because it is the back-up. A computer breaks down, a battery dies, a device floods. The table in your pocket always works.
  • Because planning remains a skill. Knowing before you go how long you can stay is what separates a dive you lead from a dive that happens to you.
  • And because it is in the exam, at French Level 2 as at Level 3. You may as well see the good side.

What this history tells us

A century of tables is a century of successive models, each presented as the right answer, each corrected by the next. Haldane was wrong about his 2:1 ratio. The US Navy was wrong about its reference population. Deep stops, very fashionable in the 2000s, have since been seriously questioned.

That is not an invitation to relativism — today’s models are much better than yesterday’s. It is an invitation to modesty: no displayed figure is a guarantee, and the margin you take beyond what is displayed is yours to choose.

For what comes next, and to understand what your computer does with all this heritage: decompression algorithms.

Ready to breathe underwater?

The try dive lasts twenty minutes and needs no certification. It is where everything starts, and it comes off the course price if you carry on.

Understanding scuba diving

Also worth reading

Understanding scuba diving

Why take the nitrox course: safety first

Nitrox does not give you time, it gives you margin — less dissolved nitrogen, so decompression sickness stays further away. The question…

6 min read Read →
Understanding scuba diving

Pressure in diving: everything starts here

Absolute pressure, Boyle's law, volumes that compress: the Niveau 1 theory lesson that explains your ears, your weighting, your gas consumption and…

5 min read Read →