Give the sea! Try-dive, snorkelling, freediving, boat licence…: treat someone with a Chango Sea gift voucher.

Give a gift voucher
Skip to main content
Understanding scuba diving

Decompression algorithms compared

Bühlmann, gradient factors, RGBM, VPM, DSAT: what each model assumes, what it protects, what it costs — and why “which is best?” is the wrong question.

Every product sheet shows the name of an algorithm — Bühlmann ZH-L16C, RGBM, DSAT — and none of them explains what difference it makes. It is a selling point nobody can assess.

This article assumes you already know what comes before it: how nitrogen dissolves and comes back out, and why tissues do not all off-gas at the same speed. If those two are familiar, we can move on to the models.

A one-line reminder for those arriving from elsewhere: under pressure your body dissolves nitrogen, each tissue at its own speed, and a decompression model is there to estimate how much each one has taken on and how much it can tolerate on the way up.

Bühlmann ZH-L16: the reference model

This is the name you will see on almost every product sheet, and it refers to the work of Dr Albert Bühlmann in Zurich. The model divides the body into sixteen compartments, from the fastest to the slowest, and gives each one a maximum tolerable nitrogen tension at every depth. As long as no compartment exceeds its limit, you can ascend.

The final letter — ZH-L16 A, B or C — refers to variants of these limits. Version C is the most conservative, and it is the one used by most recreational computers.

What makes it strong

It is published. Divers underestimate this: anyone can read the equations, check them and implement them. A model that can be verified is worth more than a secret one, however good. It is also validated by decades of use, predictable, and it behaves the same way from one device to another.

Its limit

It is a dissolved gas model: it calculates quantities of nitrogen in solution, and does not model bubbles as such. Yet we now know that micro-bubbles form during perfectly compliant dives. Used raw, with no added margin, it is considered somewhat permissive.

Gradient factors: the setting that changes everything

It is the most useful addition of the last thirty years, and it is expressed as two numbers, such as 30/70 or 40/85.

The idea: rather than letting your compartments rise all the way to their theoretical limit, you decide to use only a percentage of that limit. The first number governs the start of the ascent — the lower it is, the deeper and earlier you stop. The second governs arrival at the surface — the lower it is, the more margin you keep at the most critical moment.

A 100/100 setting is raw Bühlmann. A 30/70 is clearly more conservative, at the cost of longer stops.

The advantage: you choose your safety margin instead of having it imposed. A fifty-five-year-old diver doing six days of diving in a row does not need the same margin as a twenty-five-year-old who dives once a month.

The drawback: you have to understand what you are setting. Badly chosen gradient factors are worse than the factory setting, and nobody should touch them without knowing what each of the two numbers does.

Bubble models

RGBM

The Reduced Gradient Bubble Model, developed by Bruce Wienke, starts from a different idea: since bubbles exist, you might as well model them. It is most often implemented on top of a Bühlmann-type base, with added penalties.

What it does well: it penalises the profiles that dissolved-gas theory treats too kindly — fast ascents, saw-tooth profiles, reverse dives where the second is deeper than the first, and repetitive days. In these specific cases it is more protective.

What it is criticised for: its implementations are proprietary and unpublished, so they cannot be checked. And it is frankly conservative: the no-stop time can shrink a great deal from one day to the next, which frustrates divers and — this is the real danger — pushes some to work around their own computer.

VPM

The Varying Permeability Model also reasons in terms of bubbles and imposes deep stops early in the ascent. It is mainly used in technical diving.

What it is criticised for: research carried out since the 2010s has seriously questioned the value of deep stops. By stopping early and deep, you keep loading the slow compartments while unloading the fast ones — which could, in some profiles, make things worse rather than better. The debate is not closed, but the fashion for deep stops has clearly faded.

DSAT and the permissive models

Derived from the work that produced the PADI dive table, the DSAT model still runs on some computers. It gives longer no-stop times than the others, and it was validated by real-world trials.

Its appeal: more bottom time on a simple dive, which holiday divers like.

Its limit: it is clearly less protective on repetitive dives and back-to-back days, which is exactly what a diving holiday looks like.

So which one is best?

The question is the wrong one, and that is the most useful answer in this article.

None of these models really describes what happens in your body. They are statistical approximations, calibrated on populations, that give an acceptable result for most people most of the time. None guarantees anything, and decompression sickness remains possible on a perfectly respected profile.

What matters more than the name of the algorithm:

  • Your personal margin. Hydration, cold, effort, fatigue, age, how you feel that day. The same profile does not cost the same on every day.
  • Respecting the ascent rate, the most decisive parameter of all — and the most often neglected.
  • The routine safety stop at five metres, even when the computer does not require it.
  • Regularity. A diver who dives often copes better than one coming back after six months off.

The rule within a group

It is simple and allows no exceptions.

When two divers in the same group wear different computers, they will not show the same numbers — sometimes with large gaps. You always follow the more conservative of the two, meaning the one showing the least time remaining or the most stops.

Glancing at your neighbour’s screen for reassurance and carrying on with your own is exactly what not to do. You are not diving on their body.

And at Mares

Current models are built on Bühlmann ZH-L16C with adjustable gradient factors — the choice that seems healthiest to us today: a published model, a margin chosen by the diver, and predictable behaviour from one device to another.

On the models that allow it, we set the gradient factors with you when you buy, according to how you actually dive rather than leaving the factory values to chance. It takes ten minutes, and it is probably the most useful setting on the whole device.

Ready to breathe underwater?

The try dive lasts twenty minutes and needs no certification. It is where everything starts, and it comes off the course price if you carry on.

Understanding scuba diving

Also worth reading

Understanding scuba diving

Why take the nitrox course: safety first

Nitrox does not give you time, it gives you margin — less dissolved nitrogen, so decompression sickness stays further away. The question…

6 min read Read →
Understanding scuba diving

Pressure in diving: everything starts here

Absolute pressure, Boyle's law, volumes that compress: the Niveau 1 theory lesson that explains your ears, your weighting, your gas consumption and…

5 min read Read →