Give the sea! Try-dive, snorkelling, freediving, boat licence…: treat someone with a Chango Sea gift voucher.

Give a gift voucher
Skip to main content
Understanding snorkelling

Can you touch a starfish? Teaching without harm

The question every parent asks on the boat. What it actually does to the animal, and why there is a better answer than "no, we don't touch".

It is a fair question

It comes up on every trip, and it is asked in good faith: how do you give a child the wish to protect the sea if they have never held anything in their hand? A great many of us became divers because of a starfish placed in a palm, thirty years ago, on a beach.

Answering “we don’t touch” and moving on is not an answer. Here is ours, with the reasoning behind it.

What it does to the animal

A starfish breathes through fine extensions of its skin, in direct contact with the water. Out of the water, it stops breathing. A few seconds do not kill it, contrary to what you sometimes read, but every lift is real stress — and a starfish handled by fifty people over a summer is no longer a healthy starfish. Handling also damages its tube feet, the hundreds of small tubes it uses to move and to hold on.

A sea urchin does not sting you: you stand on it. Its spines are brittle and snap off in the skin, where they stay. For the animal, a broken spine is an open wound. And for you, it is a splinter a doctor will have to remove.

Fish are covered in a mucus that protects them from infection. A hand strips it wherever it touches, and leaves an opening for parasites. That is as true of a curious sea bream as of a grouper.

Sunscreen. The detail nobody thinks of: a hand coated in cream leaves a chemical film on everything it touches. On an animal that breathes through its skin, that is not trivial.

Gorgonians and red coral grow a centimetre a year, and a few millimetres in the case of the coral. A branch broken in a second takes decades to grow back — if it grows back at all.

The real question is not “touch or not”

It is: what makes a child want to come back?

Our experience, after thousands of trips, is that the animal in the hand nearly always disappoints. A starfish out of the water does nothing: it is limp, it hangs, it is no longer a starfish but an object. The memory lasts thirty seconds.

What children talk about on the way home is something else. An octopus changing colour in a second because it saw you. A cloud of damselfish closing around them. A moray putting its head out. A sea bream coming to look into their mask. In other words: an animal alive and doing something. And none of that happens when you put your hand out — because putting your hand out makes things leave.

The paradox is worth telling children exactly as it stands: you see far more when you touch nothing.

What we do in practice

Touch the rock, not what lives on it. Steadying yourself with one finger on bare stone is perfectly acceptable.

Look very close up. A mask ten centimetres from a starfish shows infinitely more than a hand: the tube feet moving, the patterns in the skin. Going down to look beats bringing it up.

Let the animal decide. A curious octopus will sometimes come and touch a fin, or a finger held still. That is an encounter — and the child who has one does not forget it.

Photograph rather than collect. Shells, urchins, starfish: nothing goes in the bag. An empty shell on the bottom is somebody’s home.

What the law says, too

Beyond the principle, some species are protected and taking them is illegal. The fan mussel, gorgonians and red coral are regulated, and urchin fishing is limited to strict seasons. Picking up “just one” is not always only a question of conscience.

This is not giving something up

Education and protection are not opposed: they are the same thing. A child who is told why we do not touch learns two things instead of one — what the animal is, and why it matters. The ones who come back to dive ten years later are the ones who were told, not the ones who were handed something.

The best spots, by boat

Villefranche and the Mala look better from the water than from the shore — and the boat drops you where you cannot get on foot.

Understanding snorkelling

Also worth reading