Give the sea! Try-dive, snorkelling, freediving, boat licence…: treat someone with a Chango Sea gift voucher.

Give a gift voucher
Skip to main content
Understanding freediving

Blackout, samba, taravana: freediving accidents

Why the urge to breathe comes from carbon dioxide and not from lack of oxygen, what that changes, and the four rules that remove most of the risk.

What triggers the urge to breathe

Everything starts here, and almost nobody knows it.

When you hold your breath, the sensation that builds — the discomfort, then the diaphragm contractions, then the urgency — is not triggered by lack of oxygen. It is triggered by a build-up of carbon dioxide.

The body monitors two things through sensors called chemoreceptors. Some, in the brainstem, continuously measure carbon dioxide and blood acidity: they are what drives your breathing day to day, and what forces you to take a breath. The others, on the large arteries of the neck, monitor oxygen — but they only react once it has already fallen a long way.

In other words: your alarm measures the waste, not the fuel. It is perfectly suited to everyday life, where the two move together. It becomes dangerous the moment you uncouple them.

Why hyperventilation kills

Breathing fast and hard before a breath-hold does exactly that: it flushes out carbon dioxide without adding oxygen — the blood is already almost saturated, and you cannot store more.

The result: the alarm is pushed back, the freediver feels fine, they last longer. And meanwhile the oxygen falls, and falls, until the brain shuts down — with nothing having given any warning.

That is the mechanism behind almost every freediving drowning. There is no struggle, no thrashing, no call: someone simply stops. It is also why hyperventilation is forbidden in all our sessions, without exception and without discussion.

The samba

This is the warning signal, and it arrives afterwards. On the ascent or in the seconds that follow, the freediver begins to shake, loses control of their movements, and stares blankly. They are conscious, but nothing is coordinated any more.

The name comes from the look of those tremors. The thing is benign in itself and passes in a few seconds — but it means one thing only: you came very close to a blackout. A samba is not a performance, it is a warning, and the session stops there.

Blackout

Loss of consciousness through lack of oxygen. It happens most often in the last few metres of the ascent or right at the surface: as you come up, the pressure falls, the partial pressure of oxygen in the lungs collapses, and what little was left is no longer enough.

That is the cruel paradox of freediving: the most dangerous moment is not the bottom, it is the arrival. A freediver can feel perfectly fine at twenty metres and lose consciousness at three.

A blackout has no consequences whatsoever if someone is there. The buddy keeps the airway clear of the water, removes the mask, talks and blows on the face: recovery is usually immediate. With nobody there, it is a drowning.

Which is why the “never alone” rule is not a comfort measure. The great majority of fatal freediving accidents happen to people on their own, and often experienced ones — they are the ones who think themselves safe.

Barotrauma

The same as in scuba for the ears, sinuses and mask, with one difference: in freediving you have no reserve of air to equalise with. Every breath sent into the mask is taken from the lungs, which explains the low-volume mask and learning the Frenzel manoeuvre.

To which is added a risk specific to depth: lung squeeze. As you descend, the lungs compress; past a certain point, the tissue no longer follows. This concerns deep, progressive freediving, not someone going down to look at an octopus at five metres — but it is one of the reasons depth is never forced and is acquired slowly.

Taravana

A decompression accident in freediving. Long considered impossible, it is now well described: it affects people who chain deep descents with surface intervals that are too short, in the manner of the Polynesian fishermen the name comes from.

The signs are those of a classic decompression accident: dizziness, neurological disturbance, paralysis. Prevention comes down to one simple and tiresome rule: the surface interval must be long, several times the length of the previous breath-hold. It is what most beginners neglect, because waiting is boring.

What actually protects you

  • Never alone. One goes down, the other watches and meets them, right through to full recovery.
  • No hyperventilation. You breathe slowly and fully, and you never “fill up”.
  • No competition. Not between participants, not against yourself, not against last week’s number.
  • Minimal weighting. Floating at the surface, passive ascent from ten metres.
  • Long intervals between descents, especially when they follow one another.
  • And knowing when to stop: a day of tiredness, cold or irritation is not a day for depth.

Should you be worried?

No, and it is important to say so plainly. These accidents concern almost exclusively situations that our sessions rule out by design: being alone, hyperventilating, competing, and chaining deep descents without rest.

A supervised beginner, in modest depths, with an instructor counting their intervals and refusing to let them overweight, runs practically none of these risks. Freediving is dangerous when practised alone and fast. Supervised and slow, it is one of the calmest activities there is.

Try freediving, for real

A supervised introduction, with no performance and no stopwatch: above all you learn to relax. Never alone, never forced.

Understanding freediving

Also worth reading

Understanding freediving

The freediving disciplines, explained simply

Static, dynamic, constant weight, free immersion: six very different ways of holding your breath, and the one everybody starts with.

2 min read Read →